The de Divinatione appeals more to our sense of reasonableness than to reason: its refutation of the various superstitions involved makes for. An English translation. The complete work is onsite. Part of a large site on ancient Rome and classical Antiquity. Guillaumont (F.) Le De divinatione de Cicerón et les théories antiques de . Cicerone, Della divinazione (Milan, ); G. Freyburger and J. Scheid. (edd., trans.
|Published (Last):||26 June 2010|
|PDF File Size:||3.95 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||6.3 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Ennius, speaking with reference to the Roman system of augury, said: Alex Crawford marked it as to-read Jan 14, For who stands sponsor for them? This is a conclusion by no means agreeable to the astrologers; for they insist that all persons born at the same time, regardless of the place of birth, are born to the same fate. Astronomers have recorded the movements of the planets and thereby have discovered an orderly course of the stars, not thought of before.
On the other hand, how many treat them with disdain, and regard a belief in them as the superstition of a weak and effeminate mind! What is astonishing in the fact that the horse of Dionysius came up out of the river, or that it had bees in its mane?
Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. For Gaius in his letter does not state that the soothsayers expressed any opinion as to the result if neither snake had been released. A really amazing book by Cicero discussing divination. For, when people are sick, we, as a general rule, do not summon a prophet or a seer, but we call in a physician. Since you deny that God made them all you must admit that nature made them all.
Cicero on Divination
Did your ‘Aius the Speaker,’ before anybody knew who he was, both speak and talk and from that fact receive his name? Alexander, while sitting by the bedside of his friend, fell fast asleep. The three remaining distances are beyond computation: The Stoics have collected much evidence to prove it. Is there, then, in such objects some quality that we can better perceive with the aid of prophecy and inspiration than we can with the aid of the senses alone? This is especially noticeable to mariners who often observe extreme changes of weather take place while they rounding the capes.
After the celebrant has said to his assistant, “Tell me when silence appears to exist,’ the latter, without looking up or about him, immediately replies, ‘Silence appears to exist. Apr 24, Samuel Valentino rated it liked it Shelves: But if true visions are divine while the false and meaningless ones are from nature, what sort of caprice decided that God made the one and nature made the other, rather than that God made them all, which your school denies, or that nature made them all?
In fact dreams would be less regarded on their own account and would be viewed with greater indifference had they not been taken under the guardianship of philosophers — not philosophers of the meaner sort, but those of the keenest wit, competent to see what follows logically and what does not — men who are considered well-nigh perfect and infallible. The prophecies made by the soothsayers from these events were fulfilled to the letter.
De Divinatione – Wikipedia
Under the same head you included practically every method of prophecy in which conjecture was employed. Return to Book Page. The site where the stone was found is religiously guarded to this day. Are we to say that it was invented by the Pisidians, Cilicians, or Phrygians? May 14, Birch rated it it was amazing. And so when he had broken open the stone, the lots sprang forth carved on oak, in ancient characters. Aisling03 rated it really liked it Jan 01, Surely nothing is so at variance with reason and stability as chance?
However, Diogenes the Stoic makes some concessions to the Chaldeans. Passing by men of cicerons day, let us take Marcus Crassus. There are certain indications from the condition of divinayione pulse and breath cicerobe from many other cicrone in sickness by means of which physicians foretell the course of a disease.
Etenim nobismet ipsis quaerentibus quid sit de divinatione iudicandum, quod a Carneade multa acute et copiose contra Stoicos disputata sint, verentibusque ne temere vel falsae rei vel non satis cognitae adsentiamur, faciendum videtur ut diligenter etiam atque etiam argumenta cum argumentis comparemus, ut fecimus in iis tribus libris quos de natura deorum scripsimus. Nam et maiorum instituta tueri sacris caerimoniisque retinendis sapientis est, et esse praestantem aliquam aeternamque naturam, et eam suspiciendam admirandamque hominum generi pulchritudo mundi ordoque rerum caelestium cogit confiteri.
Had he foreseen that in the Senate, chosen in most part by himself, in Pompey’s hall, aye, before Pompey’s very statue, and in the presence of many of his own centurions, divinarione would be put to death by most noble citizens, some of whom owed all that they had to him, and that he would fall to so low an estate that no friend — no, not even a slave — would approach his dead body, in what agony of soul would he have spent his life!
Personal life Political career Writings. Vedi le condizioni d’uso per i dettagli.
So much that in some cases they were directly the reverse of each other. Ana Enriques rated it liked it May xivinatione, For when the entrails of the first victim have been without a head, which is the most fatal of all signs, it often happens that the sacrifice of the next victim is altogether favourable.
There is a head to the liver and a heart in the entrails, presto! In some cases he does a good job of ridiculing the pract A good discussion of the possibility of divination, between Cicero and his real-life brother Quintus. Do you Stoics fail to see in choosing the victim it is almost like a throw of the dice, especially as facts prove it?
What he sees divinationr causes him no astonishment even though he does not know how it happened. Erica rated it really liked it Feb 26, In the first place, what difference does its location make?
Again, however, when, and by whom, shall we say that the system was invented? Aye, some god will snatch them away! His whole address was devoted to an exposition of the science of soothsaying. The thicker the border, the more information. MarmoraleMilano, Carlo Signorelli Editore,p.